Bracelet électronique.JPG from Wikimedia Commons by Jérémy-Günther-Heinz Jähnick, CC-BY-SA 3.0

Wilson Solicitors LLP acts for Mark Nelson, a car mechanic and father of five, who has been subjected to 24/7 surveillance by way of a GPS ankle tag by the Home Office for almost 22 months.  

Mark challenged the Home Office’s decision to GPS tag him on the basis it is an unjustified intrusion into his privacy, under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (‘ECHR’). Mark also argued that it was unlawful to make him wear a tag which was broken for almost six months.

This was the first court case to consider the lawfulness of the Home Office’s policy of GPS tagging migrants. 

As there have been no other court judgments on this policy yet, the Home Office has to date been ‘marking its own work’. The main way it is supposed to be doing this is by reviewing the necessity of GPS tagging at least every three months, as required by the Home Office’s own policy. Throughout Mark’s case, however, the Home Office failed to conduct lawful or timely reviews, leading the court to find that making Mark wear a tag amounted to a breach of his rights for over a year under Article 8 ECHR and was a public law error. 

The court also agreed with Mark’s arguments that it was unlawful for the Home Office to tag him for the six months when the Home Office knew it was not working. 

The court’s findings follow the recent decision by the Information Commissioner's Office (‘the ICO’ - the UK’s data protection regulator) on the Home Office’s use of people’s data under its pilot GPS tagging scheme. The ICO issued a formal warning that ‘any future processing by the Home Office on the same basis will be in breach of data protection law and will attract enforcement action.’ 

However, the court found that wearing the tag at the time of the hearing was proportionate and Mark continues to be tagged. Since this is the first case assessing the proportionality of this intrusive technology, given the large number of people this issue affects and given the ongoing impact of the tag on Mark, Mark intends to apply for permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal on this point.

Mark says:

This tag is inhumane, pointless and brutal. I am proud we won on so many important points today, but I intend to keep fighting so that the Home Office can no longer subject people to this cruel and dystopian technology. 

Katie Schwarzmann, Mark’s solicitor, says:

This judgment is a lesson to the Home Office that it is not above the law when it subjects people to 24/7 surveillance. It can no longer impose such intrusive forms of surveillance on people without regard for whether the technology is working or whether it is – and continues to be – absolutely necessary. 

Mark is represented by Katie Schwarzmann of Wilson Solicitors LLP, Donnchadh Greene of Doughty Street Chambers and Sarah Hannett KC of Matrix Chambers. Evidence relating to the functionality of GPS tags was provided by Privacy International.  

Wilson Solicitors LLP represents a number of individuals challenging the Home Office’s imposition of GPS tags on them. 

If you have a family law case you need assistance with, please contact Mavis on 0202 8885 7986 to arrange for an appointment with a solicitor in the family team.

Date and Time

Location

Featured Lawyer(s)

Latest News

Saturday appointments are available at our Central London office with Ana Gonzalez by prior arrangement.

Wilson Solicitors LLP is a limited liability partnership, registered in England and Wales with registered no OC347380. The registered office is the above address. Wilson Solicitors LLP is regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority of England and Wales with registered no 520695. The principal applicable professional rules are the Solicitors' Code of Conduct. We use the word 'partner' to refer to a member of the LLP, or an employee or consultant who is a lawyer with equivalent standing and qualifications. A list of members' names and a list of those non-members who are designated as partners are open to inspection at the registered office. The partners are solicitors of England and Wales. VAT no 553990412

© Copyright 2023 Wilson Solictor LLP All Rights Reserved.

Built by: TribeSquared