Senior associate Sarah Colley reviews a recent judgment in the High Court, in Crowther v Crowther & Ors [2020] EWHC 3555 (Fam), which reiterates the principles surrounding when costs should be paid in circumstances where allegations of fraud and conspiracy have been made.

The case concerned a husband and wife, who had run a shipping business together worth approximately £7-£10 million, and their financial remedy proceedings which had been ongoing since 2019. There was dispute as to who the beneficial owners of the ships were hence Mr Knight and the ‘Castle parties’ being parties to the proceedings.

The wife alleged fraud and conspiracy against the husband and Mr Knight, who was the second Respondent in the financial proceedings, stating that they had set out to defraud HMRC and her in the proceedings mostly by concluding contracts with companies controlled by the husband to new companies. Both the husband and Mr Knight strenuously denied the allegations.

The case was listed for a preliminary hearing to consider the allegations and other issues such as whether the husband and wife were indebted to the ‘Castle parties’ and who the beneficial owners of the ships were.

A week prior to the hearing, the wife and the Castle parties reached an agreed settlement and informed the Court that they wished to vacate the hearing. The wife agreed that this would result in all allegations of fraud and conspiracy against the husband being discontinued.

The husband was not a party to the agreed settlement and subsequently applied for his costs, on an indemnity basis, incurred in relation to dealing with the allegations made by the wife and a payment of £80,000.

Mrs Justice Lieven confirmed in her judgment the principles and the case law in so far as claiming costs is concerned. The case-law makes it very clear that a party who pleads fraud unsuccessfully can expect to pay indemnity costs. The Judge was clear that there was no reason why that principle should not apply in this case. The wife was therefore ordered to pay the husband’s costs as sought together with £80,000 payment on account.

If you require advice or assistance with a financial remedy case from a specialist solicitor, contact Mavis on 020 8885 7986 for an appointment.

If you have a family law case you need assistance with, please contact Mavis on 0202 8885 7986 to arrange for an appointment with a solicitor in the family team.

Date and Time


Featured Lawyer(s)

No items found.

Latest News

Saturday appointments are available at our Central London office with Ana Gonzalez by prior arrangement.

Wilson Solicitors LLP is a limited liability partnership, registered in England and Wales with registered no OC347380. The registered office is the above address. Wilson Solicitors LLP is regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority of England and Wales with registered no 520695. The principal applicable professional rules are the Solicitors' Code of Conduct. We use the word 'partner' to refer to a member of the LLP, or an employee or consultant who is a lawyer with equivalent standing and qualifications. A list of members' names and a list of those non-members who are designated as partners are open to inspection at the registered office. The partners are solicitors of England and Wales. VAT no 553990412

© Copyright 2023 Wilson Solictor LLP All Rights Reserved.

Built by: TribeSquared