H (A Child - Surrogacy Breakdown) [2017] EWCA Civ 1798

It is invariably tragic, even for family lawyers, to read about the acrimonious relationships people find themselves in concerning children. In this case two couples entered into a surrogacy arrangement and sadly the relationship between the couples broke down before the child was born resulting in the surrogate and her husband deciding not to honour the surrogacy arrangement after the birth of the child. In this case, A and B, a male same sex couple, were the intended parents of H. A donor egg was used and A is H’s biological father. C and D, a married same sex couple, fell out with A and B and decided not to fulfil the surrogacy arrangement. Instead they registered H’s birth and did not inform the intended parents until some 10 days after H’s birth. As a result A and B made an application to the court. The court was asked to determine:

  1. Who H should live with;
  2. How much contact H should have with the other couple;
  3. The extent to which the other couple should be able to exercise their legal parental responsibility for H.

The Judge decided to make an Order that H lives with the intended parents, limited H’s contact with C and D to six times annually and made a series of orders limiting C and D’s ability to exercise parental responsibility. Although C and D sought to appeal, their appeal was dismissed. The case is interesting because it enhances the recognition of surrogacy arrangements and arguably lends credence to the school of thought that these arrangements should be recognised legally.

If you have a family law case you need assistance with, please contact Mavis on 0202 8885 7986 to arrange for an appointment with a solicitor in the family team.

Date and Time


Featured Lawyer(s)

No items found.

Latest News

Saturday appointments are available at our Central London office with Ana Gonzalez by prior arrangement.

Wilson Solicitors LLP is a limited liability partnership, registered in England and Wales with registered no OC347380. The registered office is the above address. Wilson Solicitors LLP is regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority of England and Wales with registered no 520695. The principal applicable professional rules are the Solicitors' Code of Conduct. We use the word 'partner' to refer to a member of the LLP, or an employee or consultant who is a lawyer with equivalent standing and qualifications. A list of members' names and a list of those non-members who are designated as partners are open to inspection at the registered office. The partners are solicitors of England and Wales. VAT no 553990412

© Copyright 2023 Wilson Solictor LLP All Rights Reserved.

Built by: TribeSquared